This was originally written for The Huffington Post. (Link to be added when it goes live)
Reading Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo’s brand new issue of Batman, you’d think they’ve been doing this for the whole of their lives. They’ve created a look and feel for Batman that seems iconic and old, but all at once their own. From the opening pages of Batman #13, you get the feeling that something isn’t right, it has that unsettling gravitas that only one force in Gotham can conjure: The Joker.
Absent as a central villain in DC’s New 52, Batman #13 propels Joker into the spotlight once again. And it’s lethal, scary, and unsettling.
And it’s supposed to be.
This Joker is one so uniquely Scott that it’s not fair to compare it to others. It has the whimsy of Mark Hamill’s Joker (though Scott tells me it’s his secret fanboy dream to shake Mark Hamill’s hand, not just because of the fact that he’s Luke Skywalker, but because he created one of the best Jokers in Batman’s history.) Scott’s Joker has the calculated chaos of Heath Ledger’s Joker, and even some of the cool confidence of Jack Nicholson’s.
This Joker is incredibly fun to read, but nerve-wracking at the same time. What horror is going to befall my beloved heroes?
In an interview last week, Scott explained to me about how be became interested in the family Batman has accumulated and how, “as a sort of father, he’s vulnerable and frightened for their safety. And I thought to myself who would be the most frightening in that situation. That’s Joker. Joker is about that thing that looks at you and knows what you’re afraid of and knows how to exploit it.”
The last time I interviewed Scott about Joker, he told me something about his take on the Joker that I think still resonates: “I think Joker works best as a demon on Bruce’s shoulder. He’s bringing horrifying things to life for Bruce…”
And reading this issue, it’s true. Knowing that Snyder and his team seem to have carte blanche in the Bat universe, I’m starting to become very afraid for some of my favorite ancillary characters in the Bat-universe. I’m most terrified for Tim Drake, former Robin, current Red Robin, who isn’t headlining his own book. Reading this first issue, it feels clear that no one is safe, and Joker has a habit of taking out Robins. In fact, the title Death of the Family hearkens back to my favorite Batman story, Batman: Death in the Family, which is about the time Joker beat Jason Todd, the second Robin, to death with a crow bar and blew him up.
Bad things are going to happen and I’m not sure I can handle it. Even just thinking about it as I write this piece I’m getting uneasy.
But that’s really a testament to the team working on the book. Scott brings a tremendous literary quality to the writing, showing us what Batman is made of by doing the most horrible of things to him. Greg Capullo is giving us some of the best pencils in his career, and FCO Plascencia is doing the most atmospheric colors of his life. Speaking of the rest of his crew, Scott told me that he’s “honored to be working with this art team. Batman has never been as richly imagined.”
I agree with him.
This is a book you need to read. Whether you’re a fan of comics or not. If you’re a fan of good storytelling and can buy into the conceit that a man dressed as a bat can make a difference in the world, then there’s no better book for you than this one.
Batman #13 hits comic book stores on Wednesday.
Bryan Young is an author and the editor in chief of the geek news and review site Big Shiny Robot!
And then, Androidika, a fellow Big Shiny Robot!, offers his impressions of the issue:
The following review does touch upon a couple of story points which could be considered minor spoilers, but I don’t reveal anything major. You have been warned.
It isn’t often that you finish reading a comic and you immediately say to yourself “This is something special.” Well that was the case as soon as I finished reading Batman #13. Scott Snyder started writing in the bat-verse in Detective Comics (Pre New-52) with the much acclaimed story, The Black Mirror. He moved on to work with Greg Capullo on the highly praised Court of Owls story in Batman. Now we come to Batman #13, the first part in the “Death of the Family” story arc that sees the return of the Joker. The Joker’s return is something that has been anticipated since he cut off his face and disappeared.
This first issue sets the tone for the rest of the story. The Joker has some master plan for Batman and his family of characters. The Joker thinks that the bat-family is slowing down Batman. So he’s going to remove them from the equation. I can’t help but think of Zoom from the Flash comics and how he did horrible things to Wally West to “Make him a better hero.” We don’t know how the Joker will enact his plan yet, but what he does have planned is so horrible that it even frightens Harley Quinn, who is having mixed feelings because the Joker isn’t acting like her “Mr J” anymore. I would go so far as to say as readers this isn’t our “Mr J” anymore either. This is the most frightening version of the Joker I have read. He is more calculating and unpredictable than he’s ever been, and that is a scary thing! “Death of the Family” not only pays homage to, but seems like Snyder and Capullos love letter to “A Death in the Family” and “The Killing Joke.” This whole issue was suspenseful and thrilling all the way through, and has a last page cliffhanger that is just jaw dropping!
Now it wouldn’t be fair if I didn’t bring up how beautiful the art is on this book! Until this point Greg Capullo had been doing the work of his life on this book, and this issue takes it to a whole new level! The dark tone of the city is just breathtaking and the way the Joker is drawn is flat out scary. From the pencils to the inks to the colors and even the lettering, this art team has hit their groove and is working like a well-oiled machine to put out some fantastic pages!
Most creative teams that are on a book for a fair amount of time have that one story that defines or solidifies their run as something people will remember forever. This very well could be that story for Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo.
This issue hits stores this Wednesday, October 10th and will feature a special die cut cover. I would highly recommend adding it to your pull list or getting to your comic shop when it opens because this issue will definitely sell out! And for those of you looking for more “Death of the Family” story Batgirl #13 is also out this week, will also feature a die cut cover, and is labeled as a “prelude” to this story.